Comparison of Two Leading Shredded Memory Foam Head Pillows


According to the independent mattress and pillow review site Sleep Like the Dead, the two top-rated brands of memory foam pillows are Snuggle-Pedic and Coop Home Goods. On Snuggle-Pedic Ultra Luxury, the Snuggle-Pedic Ultra Luxury and the Coop Home Goods PREMIUM Adjustable Loft (Original) are #2 and #4 respectively, the top two memory foam head pillows with 1,000+ customer reviews.  #1 is a body pillow, and #3 a travel neck pillow.

These two pillows are each filled with shredded memory foam, and each is covered with a blend of rayon from bamboo and polyester, making them largely comparable.

(CHG Original = Coop Premium Adjustable Loft on Amazon)

Feature Coop Home Goods Original Snuggle-Pedic Ultra Luxury
Adjustability Adjustable Adjustable
Memory Foam type 1 type, finely shredded 2 types, finely shredded, regular and Biogreen
Source of Foam Source unstated Trimmings from mattress slabs – same quality of foam
Certification CertiPUR-US CertiPUR-US for regular foam
Biogreen exceeds GreenGuard Gold standard 13x (tested by UL)
Additional foam for free Less than 50% Up to 50%
Cover Materials 40% Bamboo Rayon
60% Polyester
43% Bamboo Rayon
56.4% Polyester
0.6% Lycra
Cover features Blended fiber knit cover
Tightly-knit polyester liner
Cover and liner zippered to enable adjustment of filling content

Thick knit w/ stitched micro-vents for extra breathability
tightly-knit polyester liner
Cover and liner zippered to enable adjustment of filling content

Place of Manufacture California, USA California, USA
Sleep Trial/Return Period 30 Days
No free return shipping if bought on Amazon
90 days
Free return shipping if bought on Amazon (contact S-P directly)
Warranty 5 Years 20 Years
Average Amazon customer rating (# rev.) as of 8/31/17 4.3/5.0 (13,496) 4.5/5.0 (7,893)